Mada Masr
Editor-in-chief of the Mada Masr website, Lina Attalah

Recusal hearing set, likely delaying Lina Attalah’s retrial

Mohamed Napolion
Published Tuesday, November 17, 2026 - 15:52

Mada Masr’s defense team has formally filed a request seeking the recusal of Judge Mohamed Mubarak, potentially delaying the retrial of the outlet’s Editor-in-Chief, Lina Attalah, scheduled for Wednesday. The request is scheduled for a hearing on Nov. 26 by the 12th Civil Circuit of the Abbassia Court of Appeal, Mada Masr lawyer Hassan El-Azhary said.

Attalah is facing a retrial in Case No. 3219 of 2024 after her defense team discovered that she had been sentenced in absentia to one year in prison. They learned of the ruling while completing her release procedures in a separate case, in which the court fined her 3 million Egyptian pounds ($55,700), ordered Mada Masr closed and confiscated its equipment.

El-Azhary said the 9th Circuit of the Fifth Settlement Misdemeanor Court, presided over by Judge Mohamed Mubarak, had been formally notified of the recusal request and the date set for its hearing.

The defense team acknowledged receipt of the notification on Monday and will submit a copy as part of its supporting documents when it attends Wednesday’s session to complete the necessary legal procedures.

The misdemeanor court had been scheduled to resume Attalah’s retrial on Wednesday. However, El-Azhary told Al Manassa that the judge cannot proceed with the case until the recusal request has been decided. The court is therefore expected to adjourn the proceedings pending a ruling on the request.

Explaining the grounds for the request, El-Azhary said its main basis was that Judge Mohamed Mubarak had already formed a preconceived opinion about the case.

“The judge has already expressed an opinion in a case involving the same parties, a similar incident, the same alleged act and the same charges. He has already taken a position on the matter, which is in itself sufficient legal grounds for his recusal,” El-Azhary said.

The Civil and Commercial Procedure Code allows defendants and litigants to seek a judge’s recusal to safeguard judicial impartiality and ensure fair proceedings. Grounds for recusal include hostility or a dispute between the judge and one of the parties that could compromise the judge’s impartiality, or a previously expressed opinion or preconceived position on the subject of the case that could prevent the judge from considering it objectively.

Under the law, once a recusal request has been formally submitted and the required procedures completed, proceedings in the original case must be suspended until a competent circuit of the Court of Appeal rules on the grounds presented. 

The court may reject the request, impose a fine on the applicant and return the case to the original circuit, or accept the request, remove the judge and transfer the case to another judicial circuit.

Following the Oct. 27 ruling, the Supreme Judicial Council defended the court’s refusal to grant Attalah’s defense team a postponement. The council said the outlet’s editor-in-chief had paid the fine and formally waived her right to appeal in writing.

Attalah’s defense team subsequently said in a statement that she had never waived her right to appeal. The lawyers said they had approached the New Cairo Prosecution Office to initiate appeal proceedings against the Oct. 27 ruling but had received no response by the end of the day. They were also unable to obtain the case file or an official copy of the judgment.

The United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights on Nov. 10 urged Egyptian authorities to immediately halt what it described as an alarming escalation in attacks on press freedom and the targeting, prosecution and harassment of independent journalists. It called for the immediate and unconditional release of all six Matsadaash journalists and an end to the ongoing legal proceedings against Mada Masr editor-in-chief Lina Attalah.